EFSA updates risk assessment on Alternaria toxins in food and feed

Following a mandate from the European Commission, the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) Panel on Contaminants in the Food Chain (CONTAM Panel) has published an updated Scientific Opinion evaluating the risks to animal and public health linked to Alternaria toxins in food and feed. Building on EFSA’s 2011 evaluation alongside newly identified studies from a targeted literature search and data from the EFSA Scientific Data Warehouse, the assessment examines eight fungal secondary metabolites predominantly produced by species of the genus Alternaria (in particular A. alternata): alternariol (AOH), alternariol monomethyl ether (AME), altenuene (ALT), altertoxins I and II (ATX-I, ATX-II), stemphyltoxin III (STTX-III), tenuazonic acid (TeA), and tentoxin (TEN).

The evaluation draws on a dataset of 57,104 analytical results from 16,283 food samples collected between 2015 and 2024 across 16 EU countries, in addition to feed data. However, EFSA noted significant uncertainties: 87% of the food data were left-censored (below the limit of quantification), and current analytical methods are applicable only to selected toxins, with harmonised methodologies, standards, and detection capabilities for conjugated metabolites still lacking.

In its public health evaluation, the CONTAM Panel highlighted distinct toxicological profiles across the chemical groups. Both AOH and AME were confirmed to induce DNA damage via a non-threshold mechanism, with estimated mean chronic dietary exposures exceeding the threshold of toxicological concern (TTC) of 2.5 ng/kg body weight (bw) per day (established for substances with potential DNA-reactive mutagenic and/or carcinogenic properties )across most population groups. Similarly, ATX-I, ATX-II, and STTX-III were also identified as genotoxic, although insufficient occurrence data prevented the panel from applying the TTC approach to these metabolites.

By contrast, dietary exposures for the non-genotoxic toxins ALT and TEN remained below the Cramer Class III TTC of 1,500 ng/kg bw per day, pointing to a low probability of adverse health effects. Meanwhile, tenuazonic acid (TeA) showed the highest occurrence levels overall, particularly in mulberries, paprika powder, and processed tomato products. While the available genotoxicity data for TeA remained inconclusive, the panel concluded with 98% certainty that dietary exposure across all population groups would not exceed the Cramer Class III TTC for non-genotoxic effects. Moreover, due to the absence of health-based guidance values or toxicological reference points, EFSA could not assess the risk arising from combined exposure to multiple Alternaria toxins.

For animals, the panel identified genotoxicity as the critical effect of AOH, AME, ATX-I, ATX-II, and STTX-III in long-living species. Among short-living animals, adverse effects were deemed unlikely for chickens for fattening exposed to AOH and AME, whereas risks for other species could not be characterised. Furthermore, conservative dietary exposure estimates for chickens exposed to TeA reached up to 10% of the lowest observed adverse effect level (LOAEL). Overall, persistent data gaps precluded full animal risk characterisation for ALT, ATX-I, ATX-II, STTX-III, and TEN.

To address these limitations, EFSA issued specific recommendations calling for the development and harmonisation of sensitive analytical methods (including for conjugated forms), the identification of exposure biomarkers, further investigations into the genotoxicity of TeA and combined toxicological effects, and enhanced occurrence monitoring across European food and feed chains.

 

Source:

EFSA Journal