Controversy surrounds EU's discussion on confirmation of two dangerous pesticides use
Environmental and health advocacy groups express concerns as the European Union considers confirming the authorization of two hazardous pesticides, captan and 8-hydroxyquinoline. The news, brought to light by Pesticide Action Network Europe (PAN Europe), has prompted calls for the European Commission to ban these substances. The proposed renewal of captan and 8-hydroxyquinoline has sparked skepticism due to contradicting scientific conclusions from the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA), which highlighted critical areas of concern.
Captan, a widely used fungicide in Europe, is suspected to be carcinogenic and toxic to reproduction. Additionally, it has potential associations with Parkinson's disease, and it could have neurotoxic effects (which, however, remain understudied). Furthermore, captan poses significant risks to wildlife, aquatic life, and non-target insects.
Surprisingly, Austria has advocated for its continued use in open fields and greenhouses, a stance that has now been adopted by the European Commission, despite what critics deem as unrealistic and unscientific risk mitigation measures.
The other pesticide in question, 8-hydroxyquinoline, has been flagged as harmful to reproduction and the fetus, in addition to pose a severe environmental risk to aquatic life. According to PAN Europe, its proposed renewal for use in permanent greenhouses bypasses the regulations for highly hazardous substances.
PAN Europe, along with other organizations, urges EU countries to reject the reauthorization proposals. They have expressed dissatisfaction with the discussions within the EU pesticide committee (SCoPAFF), where measures to limit captan's use in greenhouses were repeatedly blocked by Austria, Italy, and Poland. The subsequent change in the European Commission's stance, based on an allegedly flawed risk assessment from Austria, has raised concerns about the decision-making process.
As the debate intensifies, environmentalists and health advocates continue to pressure the European Union to prioritize public safety and the preservation of ecosystems by reevaluating the authorization of these hazardous pesticides.
Source:
EU faces backlash over omnibus proposal granting unlimited pesticide approvals
Environmental and health advocates are sounding the alarm over a new European Commission proposal that could grant permanent licenses to dozens of synthetic pes [...]
Industrial chemicals and pesticides threaten gut health and antibiotic effectiveness
A new study conducted by researchers from the University of Cambridge has revealed that hundreds of chemicals commonly found in pesticides and industrial produc [...]
